Blogs

US auto finance Industry, the cut-throat world of captive OEM financiers

The auto sales in the US grew at a CAGR of 7% between Sep. 2011 to Sep. 2016. In the same period, auto loan balance grew at a CAGR of 7.7%.

The captive OEMs increased their share of retail loans on the back of subvention programs supported by their parent companies. The captive OEMs had the second highest share of total loan balance amounting nearly $250 billion in 2015. Televisory analysed few of the captive OEM financiers, which have the majority market share in new car financing and are a major participant in lease financing such as Toyota Motor Credit Corporation (TMCC), Ford Motor Credit Company LLC (FMCC), American Honda Finance Corporation (AHFC). 

The captive OEMs are generally more inclined towards lease financing due to greater technical know-how in comparison to other categories of auto financiers. The AHFC has a higher proportion of lease financing followed by TMCC and FMCC.

A higher share of lease financing impacts financing margin owing to increased charges towards depreciation on operating leases. A combination of portfolio mix, average revenue per vehicle financed, interest rates charged on auto loans and lease finance, gross asset yield, the cost of debt and delinquency ratio impacts the bottom line of captive OEM financiers. The below charts show how each of these factors impacted EBT margin of TMCC, FMCC and AHFC.

TMCC had the highest revenue per vehicle financed due to the range of products offered. Toyota Motors mostly serve elite consumers, while Ford and Honda target middle-class consumers. Additionally, despite the lowest revenue per vehicle financed, AHFC enjoyed higher yield on earning assets and higher financing margin than its peers. This can be directly attributed to higher APR (Annual Percentage Rate) charged by these companies. The APR offered by TMCC, FMCC and AHFC for lease financing was 2.97%, 3.10% and 3.13% respectively in Sept. 2016. The retail financing APR was recorded at 0% for Ford and Toyota and 1.99% for American Honda Finance during the same period. 

A higher APR charged by AHFC led to greater yield on earning assets and higher financing margin. However, higher interest expense (in the case of TMCC and FMCC) and greater depreciation expense (in the case of AHFC) also impacted financing margin. TMCC had a higher share of operating leases in its portfolio leading to more depreciation expense as compared to FMCC, this, in turn, led to low financing margin for TMCC. On the other hand, TMCC had higher revenue and earning assets, this generated better yield on earning assets as compared to Ford. These factors led to a minor difference in financing margin among the three companies. Furthermore, the increasing share of operating lease contracts and rise in interest expense for the three firms resulted in declining financing margin over the years. A low yield and low financing margin translated into low EBT margins.

Although, the above factors are revenue drivers, controlling cost metrics is also significant to generate better EBT margins. 

In addition, as consumer debt levels increased in the US, the companies were forced to lend to subprime borrowers impacting their delinquency ratio negatively. Thus, all the three companies recorded a slight increase in default frequency percentage. Subsequently, as the default frequency rises, the allowances for credit losses also increases along with loss severity per unit, thereby raising the costs and impacting the EBT margins negatively. However, captive OEM financiers are more inclined to cater to super prime and prime borrowers and consequently had a very minimal impact on their delinquency ratio and margins. Therefore, it can be stated that a slight increase in delinquencies leads to a higher difference in EBT margin. Toyota Motors had the highest default frequency as compared to FMCC and AHFC. While AHFC and FMCC had the same level of delinquency, FMCC was also burdened with the highest interest expenses, thereby adding to downward pressure on its EBT margin.  

Thus to summarise, the reasons behind low EBT margin of TMCC, despite the highest revenue per vehicle financed was the low gross yield on earning assets, higher delinquency ratio and high depreciation expense. However, Ford’s lower EBT margin was mainly due to high-interest expense coupled with the low gross yield on earning assets, this may have been a result of its lower inclination towards lease financing. A better gross yield on earning assets, lower delinquencies and lower cost of debt were reasons because of which AHFC had the highest EBT margin among all its competitors.

The minor differences in the KPIs of these three major captive auto financiers had a cascading effect and led to major differences in their bottom line profitability. Hence, maintaining consistently higher EBT margin, lower interest expense and delinquencies is essential to survive in the environment of cut-throat competition. 

 

 

Your Rating

Used car market in India, online start-ups organising the sector

Per capita car ownership is low as compared to other developed nations and the global average Used cars were not a preferred means of ownership due to lack of trust among buyers and...

Unnoticed growth of the media and entertainment industry in India

Overall industry brief Growth of the M&E industry and its segments Major supporting elements of this growth   Media and Entertainment (M&E) is a very wide industry...

Can PepsiCo turnaround the performance of its North American beverage segment?

What led to the consistent decline of PepsiCo’s trademark drinks in the last few years? Can the recent improvement in top-line numbers for PepsiCo’s beverage segment be maintained in...

Analysing the price behaviour of the volatile cryptocurrency market

A brief introduction on the types of cryptocurrencies Reasons for the spike in 2017 and the slump in 2018 Is cryptocurrency a bubble?   On November 15, 2018, the...

Sri Lankan economic and political crisis

Sri Lanka’s latest political crisis, who governs the nation? Poor economic indicators adding to the nation’s woes   Sri Lanka is currently embroiled in a political crisis,...

Failure of Amazon in China, an analysis

E-commerce market in China Online consumer product retailers in China Performance of Amazon in China   Amazon is a global e-commerce player selling a wide...

Network densification and data speed in India, are HetNet and small cells a solution?

Worldwide data speed, where does India stand? Reasons for slow internet speed and status of the Indian telecom tower infrastructure How small cells fulfil data speed requirement...

SAP’s acquisition of Qualtrics, a costly affair or a strategic move?

History and evolution of SAP and ERP. Will experience measurement add value to SAP ERP?   On November 12, 2018 ERP software giant SAP announced an $8 billion acquisition...

Battle of the Low-Cost Carriers

The aviation industry has witnessed a mammoth growth in the last decade. IATA or the International Air Transport Association reported that revenues in the sector increased to $746 billion (2014)...

E-wallets dominate China, an analysis of the trend

E-Wallets: meaning and classification Widespread acceptance of e-wallets in China Comparison of PayPal, WeChat and Alipay on the operational parameters   E-wallets...

Coca-Cola remains a popular brand despite changing consumer preferences

Rising health concerns have triggered the global sugar war How is Coca-Cola surviving in the war? What makes Coca-Cola a popular company among consumers as well as in the equity...

Global jewellery retail industry and the growth of jewellery retail chains

  The annual global jewellery retail sales have grown at a CAGR of around 5% from USD 146 billion in 2005, this is expected to reach USD 250 billion in 2017. The top 5 regions for the...

A study of moissanite jewellery industry and its global market

Moissanite is used as an alternative to diamond jewellery. It is regarded at par with the diamond when compared on the basis of quality and physical properties. Moreover, moissanite glitter more...

An analysis of Malaysian rubber glove industry

How big is the international rubber gloves market? Reasons behind the healthy and steady growth Malaysia’s role in the industry Why are companies struggling for stable...

Housing finance market in India. Is affordable housing driving the growth?

Overview of the housing finance sector in India Key players dominating the segment and their dynamics Factors driving aggressive demand for housing   The housing...

Recovery still far away in the global graphite electrode manufacturing industry

The graphite electrodes find application mainly in the steel manufacturing through Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) route. EAF steel is mainly produced in EAFs by melting steel scrap through the...

Tire manufacturing industry, analysing the cost and margin trends

The global market for tire manufacturing stands at $180 billion. Michelin anticipates the long-term demand to rise at the rate of 5 to 10% a year in developing markets and 1 to 2% a year in mature...

Big and small banks, is size, the key? Elucidated through key benchmarks

The banking industry has undergone a tremendous amount of change in the past 8 years as a result of the 2008 financial crisis. During this period, many small and large banks performed badly,...

Flying vehicles, could it be a reality?

Flying vehicles and potential advantages Companies involved in the manufacturing of flying vehicles Challenges faced by developers in the development and adoption of flying...

IBC is the need of the hour for the Indian NPAs mess?

The state of NPAs in India Introduction of IBC and other measures taken in the country What happened till date?   Non-performing assets (NPAs) or bad loans arises...